Get ready for a deep dive into the world of fan theories and canon continuity as we explore the intriguing relationship between 'The Big Bang Theory' and its prequel, 'Young Sheldon'.
The Contradictions and the Quest for Answers
For fans of 'The Big Bang Theory', the arrival of 'Young Sheldon' brought with it a series of intriguing questions and contradictions. Why do these two shows, seemingly connected by the beloved character of Sheldon Cooper, differ so greatly in their portrayal of key characters and events? Is it a deliberate choice, a lack of concern for continuity, or a long-standing misrepresentation of Sheldon's early life?
Fanon to the Rescue: Fixing Canon
Enter 'Fanon Fixing Canon', a weekly column that tackles these plot holes and storyline discrepancies head-on. Through a combination of investigative work and meticulous fan theorizing, this column aims to provide solutions that restore harmony to the canon.
The Key Twist: A Memoir in the Making
The revelation that 'Young Sheldon' is, in fact, a memoir being written by adult Sheldon Cooper himself, offers a compelling explanation for the discrepancies between the two shows. This twist, hinted at in the aptly titled finale 'Memoir', suggests that the differences in character portrayals and events are the result of artistic license and ego-driven embellishments by the author.
The Biggest Difference: George Cooper Sr. and Meemaw
The most notable contrast between the shows is the reimagined portrayal of George Cooper Sr. In 'Young Sheldon', he is depicted as a kind-hearted, down-to-earth father, a far cry from his alcoholic and cheating self in 'The Big Bang Theory'. Similarly, Meemaw, Sheldon's grandmother, is much kinder in the prequel.
A More Adjusted Young Sheldon
'Young Sheldon' also presents a version of Sheldon (Iain Armitage) who is far better-adjusted than the one we know from 'The Big Bang Theory'. He has friends, isn't bullied as much, lives in a comfortable home, and has a generally better relationship with his family. This portrayal is a stark contrast to the offbeat childhood he described in the parent show.
Creative Liberties and the Spin-Off's Creator
Co-creator Steven Molaro has urged viewers to stop comparing 'Young Sheldon' to 'The Big Bang Theory', suggesting that the show takes creative liberties with its storytelling. However, as fans, we can't help but make these comparisons, leading us to the memoir theory, which provides a satisfying explanation for the changes.
Sheldon's Ego and the Whitewashing of Truth
Sheldon Cooper, a unique and egotistical character, is aware of his impact on future generations of young scientists. It's no surprise, then, that he would want to present himself in the best light possible in his memoir. He may have sanded down the sharper corners of his adolescence, especially in written form, where he can carefully craft his image.
Downsides to the Memoir Approach
While this approach has its benefits, it also comes with potential pitfalls. Sheldon, who struggles with keeping secrets and lying, could find himself in embarrassing situations if someone familiar with his real childhood challenges the accuracy of his memoir. But then again, has that ever stopped Sheldon when he believes he's right?
Stylistic Choices and the Memoir Theory
The memoir theory also explains the stylistic decisions made in 'Young Sheldon'. The adult Sheldon's narration and the overly complex episode titles could be seen as his unique way of presenting his story. Even the single-camera format, preferred by Annie Potts, fits neatly into this theory, emphasizing Sheldon's highly specific viewpoint.
An Unreliable Narrator and a New Viewing Experience
Treating 'Young Sheldon' as Sheldon's own version of his story transforms it into an unreliable narrator. This perspective allows viewers to enjoy both shows without the contradiction, creating a unique and intriguing viewing experience. Rewatching 'The Big Bang Theory' with this mindset can indeed turn it into a completely different show.
So, there you have it, a fan theory that not only fixes the canon but also adds a layer of depth and intrigue to the world of Sheldon Cooper. Personally, I find it fascinating how a simple twist can resolve so many discrepancies and open up new avenues for interpretation and enjoyment.
